Life in progress

Psychosomatic or Real?

36 Comments

Since my fall on the ice just before Christmas when I received a concussion, I’ve been having pain in my right shoulder. It wakes me up at night, has caused weakness in my right arm, and is generally a pain in the ass upper body.

So about three weeks ago I finally decided to take it to the doctor. He ordered an x-ray and an ultrasound and two weeks later I called him back because I hadn’t heard anything. His secretary said the tests showed there was nothing wrong.

But it still hurt. I made an appointment to see him.

As it turns out, I have a slight case of arthritis between my collarbone and my shoulder blade. (There’s another one of those rocket scientists at work here – not sure if it’s the secretary or the doctor, but I suspect it’s the doctor. He’s always been a bit of a twit.)

The point is, since I found out what the problem really is with my shoulder, it’s been feeling better. Is it possible to be given information that there’s nothing wrong and believe it so much that the symptoms go away? I think it is. But in my case, I’m sticking with the belief that now I know it’s not the joint, I’m no longer afraid of doing more damage. Muscle pain I can live with. I can stretch through it and I can work through it. I know now that if I use my arm more and re-build the muscle, my condition will improve.

I also know I am susceptible to psychosomatic disorders. When I get stressed it affects my skin. I itch. And no matter how much I know this to be a fact, and that there is really nothing wrong with my skin, it happens.

I posed the question above, is it psychosomatic or real, but is a psychosomatic illness any different than a real illness? They say attitude can help with the symptoms of sickness – it works both ways. It’s not all in your head. But some of it is. The mind is a powerful thing.

Have you ever suffered with something you knew was psychosomatic, and yet it persisted?

Unknown's avatar

Author: Linda G. Hill

There's a writer in here, clawing her way out.

36 thoughts on “Psychosomatic or Real?

  1. Pingback: Update on a Weirdish Week | lindaghill

  2. Oliana's avatar

    Yep, indeed I do, which one shall I share here? A month after my ex and I decided to become “ex’s” my body developed giant hives from head to toe…yep even under my feet…I could not walk…lasted 6 months…since then when under stress I gotta watch the rashes spreading fast. Always have Benadryl spray in the fridge…the coolness is also relief (that I’d add that info since your son has rashes…it may help)

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      Wow.
      I used to get eczema on my hands before my ex and I broke up… always around the ring I wore on my left ring finger. If that’s not specific I don’t know what is. 😛
      Thanks for the tip! 🙂

      Like

  3. LAMarcom's avatar

    I’m not really prone to stress, mainly because I may be too stupid to realize I need to be stressing.
    (Does that make sense?)
    Probably not.
    For the past year, I have just been going through life like Alice in Wonderland: Everything is just jim-dandy and wonderful… I think.
    Hmmm….
    Now I really need to focus on getting back overseas before I run out of my savings…

    Like

  4. foolsquest's avatar

    Similar to you, I get itchy when I’m perturbed. Which irritates me, which makes me itch more, making me even angrier. It becomes an annoyingly vicious cycle.

    Like

  5. John W. Howell's avatar

    all my illnesses once diagnosed eventually went away. Had to have been the drugs.

    Like

  6. suzjones's avatar

    I have been to the doctor countless times for pain and had tests only to be told it is nothing. I don’t believe that it was nothing. It could have been caused by a myriad of things including stress and depression.
    I’m glad you got your answer Linda and that now you have an answer it is one less thing for you to worry about.

    Like

  7. Charles Yallowitz's avatar

    Could be that knowing what’s wrong makes it less shocking.

    Like

  8. jetgirlcos's avatar

    I’m glad your shoulder is better, no matter the reason why! This post brought to mind the quote from Albus Dumbledore: “Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?” I have a relative who gets hives from stress. It’s like a panic attack, and they go away once she feels safe again. Real stuff!

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      Thank you, my dear. And thanks for the quote! I’d forgotten about that one. 🙂
      Hives are awful! I’m still trying to figure out if it’s stress or an allergy that causes them in my son.

      Like

  9. phoenixrisesagain's avatar

    Well there were a few great Greek philosophers who thought that body, mind and soul are a unity if one is affected so is the other. I deeply believe this is true. And what is a “real” illness anyway? Just one that is caused by our body? Why do we suppose our psyches are not real? They make us who we are. If they shout for help by causing physical pain we should Fu….. Listen…. Sorry for my language but I think humankind would be in a better place if we would respect the so-called “unseen” aspects of life a little more. Am glad you are feeling better now. Nothing is worse than constant pain

    Like

  10. joey's avatar

    Okay, people don’t like to say this in a public forum, but I’m feelin pretty feisty today. Arthritis is real and will not kill you, so yeah, it feels good to know! I was diagnosed at 15, and the flares suck, but otherwise, I’ve gotten used to the pain.
    Stress not only causes ailments like Paul Davis said, but it also KILLS. It’s not all in your head, but your relief is, and it’s real!
    Stress rash is also real, even if the stress is only perceived.

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      Okay, Ms. Feisty. You’re right – stress can kill. All kinds of symptoms come from it. But as I said in my comment back to Paul, I used the example of stress causing itching in opposition to something of an external reason for itching, rash, hives etc. Perhaps I explained it better in the other comment. 😛
      Stress can also be eased by a better attitude though, unlike something like cancer. Yes, the symptoms of cancer can possibly be eased, but not the disease itself.
      Is this making any sense? It does in my head. Haha.
      And yes, arthritis sucks. Funny how pain can go away to an extent when you’ve lived with it long enough.

      Like

  11. Paul Davis's avatar

    One of your kids has that stress rash, right? I think you talked about it before, otherwise I’m just a creepy stalker. I also don’t think those are psychosomatic. Stress can cause several ailments. Psychosomatic is when there isn’t anything wrong. Like the people I met who were gluten intolerant. When it was brought up, they got horribly sick when eating gluten. Then for the next week they’d eat McDonalds and Subway every day. As long as we said nothing, they could eat all the gluten they wanted. Also, knowing what exactly is wrong with your upper body allows you to prepare. You’re not afraid you’re messing it up worse.

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      I agree that stress is a real thing and there are symptoms that come from it. What I meant was, when I itch because of stress my first thought is that something bit me – but there’s nothing directly wrong with my skin. The element that causes the itch (or the hives in the case of Alex – you remembered right) isn’t from the sun, or something that was ingested, or an allergy, or an insect. When it’s stress, it’s my mind that causes it.
      But I suppose you’re right. If stress can cause a heart attack and high blood pressure, then why not something more external?
      Thanks for the comment and for sharing, Paul. 🙂

      Like

Leave a reply to Paul Davis Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.