Life in progress

Readers and Writers: Opinions Wanted

41 Comments

I had an idea: I doubt it’s a unique idea, which is why I one of my questions to you, dear readers and writers of fiction, is whether or not you’ve ever seen this done before.

Imagine being able to have a conversation with Anne Rice’s Lestat, Stephenie Meyer’s Edward Cullen, Stephen King’s Annie Wilkes, or J.R.R. Tolkien’s Galadriel. Would you want to? If an author gave voice to one of his or her characters in an interactive medium, would it be just plain weird for that character to be removed from the world the author created for them? Or would it be a thrill-ride to be able to ask all the questions you have about their lives before they showed up in the story you love? Would you enjoy flirting with your favourite fictional character? Would you like to get more insight on a villain’s inner thoughts?

I’ve seen blog posts where authors interview their characters, but to let them out in public–to relinquish control over what they might have to reveal–is a different scenario.

So I ask you, apart from the question have you seen it done before, would you want it? Or is it better to let them stay put in their story?

Unknown's avatar

Author: Linda G. Hill

There's a writer in here, clawing her way out.

41 thoughts on “Readers and Writers: Opinions Wanted

  1. jetgirlcos's avatar

    Hmmm….interesting concept, but if you take the characters out of their “world” they could learn things about your world too! Brings to mind two stories. First of all the episodes of Star Trek Next Gen concerning the character of Moriarty and then the book “Red Shirts” by John Scalzi. I found both intriguing because of the idea of the characters leaving their “stories” and learning about the world “outside.”

    Like

  2. RA Stone's avatar

    I’m planning interviews and possibly group chats with my characters. Have a friend who’s planning something similar to promote her novel. Also, Lestat? Would dominate any discussion he was in because he’s an attention hound and vain.

    Like

  3. Oliana's avatar

    I love that idea, Linda! And you could even incorporate a prompt now and then that we interview one of the characters of one of our stories, even if it is a flash fiction. That is pretty darn cool! the possibilities are endless…I like how you think, kiddo!

    Like

  4. suzjones's avatar

    I interviewed my cat once. Is that the same thing?
    Seriously though, it would be an interesting exercise. Although I would struggle to see a character such as Legolas in any way other than looking like Orlando Bloom.

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      Haha! I remember that interview. Very entertaining. 🙂 Well yeah, I was actually a little disappointed after reading LoTR half a dozen times and then seeing Orlando Bloom as Legolas… It works both ways I guess. 😛

      Like

      • suzjones's avatar

        I read all of the LoTR books before the movies and enjoyed them anyway. However I did take umbrage with some of the plot changes and extra characters written in etc. Now when I read the books, I only see Aragorn and Legolas as they were played in the movies. lol

        Like

  5. vicbriggs's avatar

    I’ve never imagined that it could be possible. I know that actors struggle with being confused with their characters in real life. An actor friend of mine once said that someone told him after a performance that he is a horrible person, apparently because the characters he had taken on were rather on the negative side. It took him all his will power not to repost: It is called “Acting!”
    Would I like to see a character come to life? I suppose it would depend on the character and what liberties they might be allowed. Out of curiosity: how would you deliver on the idea?

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      I could see myself doing a blog post “in character.” I do have to admit that when I’m writing a character I sometimes take on his or her quirks and even opinions. I can get lost in a story and in my characters for weeks. It must be extremely inconvenient for my family.

      Like

  6. quiall's avatar

    What an intriguing idea! I think I would like it best if it was a well known character. Then again interviewing one of my own characters is intriguing as well.

    Like

  7. coldhandboyack's avatar

    I interact with my characters all the time. I have to be careful not to reveal the twists and turns of the novel. My most recent story is written in a way that it would be very hard to do.

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      How do you interact? What medium do you use and who do they talk to? I’m interested. 🙂

      Like

      • coldhandboyack's avatar

        I have a Muse category on my blog. There are a few regular characters there, and other characters visit the Writing cabin regularly.

        In my mind, it provides a bit of original fiction and promotion at the same time. I also did the “Meet my Main Character” blog tour and interviewed one of my characters.

        Like

  8. eclecticalli's avatar

    Ohh! Oooh! Oooh!!!!
    So…. I’ve been talking to another blogger about this EXACT IDEA — with our own characters, of course, because those are the ones we can channel the best.
    I would actually love to organize a group of writers (small group for the first go) that would meet up on a text-chat client, each as one of their characters, and sit them all down for a “dinner party” — with the plan of polishing up the conversation and turning it into a short-story for all involved to share.
    At best, it could be amazing! At worst, a bit of a mess that never gets shown to anyone outside the participants but probably a lot of fun anyhow.
    I shall make this happen! If you’re interested, let me know and I’ll be in touch!

    Like

  9. Rebecca Meyer's avatar

    I think that authors can do this if they want, but I personally wouldn’t reveal more about my characters outside of the story. For me, I think a bit of mystery keeps things interesting for the audience, and I feel this way as a reader and a writer. As a reader, I enjoy having my own thoughts and opinions about characters, and I’m perfectly okay with them staying in the story. The mystery keeps me intersted in the book(s). As a writer, I may have numerous untold thoughts about my characters, and I enjoy letting things remain unsaid. That’s the beauty of writing. 🙂

    Like

  10. KG's avatar

    I would consider that for “Amy Dunne” in Gone Girl. That character threw me in a loop and I was left astounded. But isn’t that mystery of not exactly knowing their inner workings, alluring ?

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      There is definitely that aspect to it. Giving away too much wouldn’t be a good idea. No, the questions would have to be kept to the same sort one would ask a real human being in a polite setting. Good point. 🙂

      Like

  11. fastidiouslyme's avatar

    It’s a good idea but risky. You’d have to know the character inside&out. One line out of character and fans will hound you like a slab of raw meat.
    Pulled off well it could be successful though.

    Like

    • Linda G. Hill's avatar

      I believe any serious writer would know his or her characters that well on a personal basis. As for the lines in the book, who doesn’t remember precisely what they said at any given time? But you’re right – the author would have to be very good at remembering what they’ve written – as regular human beings we don’t write down everything we do, so it’s forgivable to forget.
      … the more I think about it as I write this comment, the more I believe you have a very good point. Thanks for that. 🙂

      Like

  12. Paul Davis's avatar

    I agree with Charles. I think it would be better for a very limited and personal audience.

    Like

  13. Charles Yallowitz's avatar

    I like that idea and I’ve tried it with mine at times. I think the challenge is finding people who read the books and want to interact. Seems it can be very hit-and-miss, but would probably get a lot of attention if it was a universally known character like Lestat or Gollum.

    Like

Leave a reply to vicbriggs Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.